Just came across this thread.
I'm not any kind of expert on the subject, but I have seen programs like this, talked to several black people about their experiences, and have been involved in a long-term interracial relationship. I've always noticed an intense diviseness that exists between the genders in the black culture, moreso than many other cultures, and I think it's very, very sad. Sure, the women on the program you mentioned were making some very racist, disparaging generalizations about black men, but if you talk to the black men who date white women exclusively, they have just as nasty things to say about black women. I've heard from black men that black women are "cold, manipulative, high-maintenance, aggressive, combative," and my ex said that he did not tend to date black women because they were "overly jealous, argumentative, and tend to make public scenes out of relaitonship upsets." From what I've observed, black music today carries a lot of these messages, with several songs from men referring to women as "bitches, ho's, and cheaters" while the songs from the women accuse men of being, "no good broke deadbeats, cheaters, and users." Women are seen as empowered for coming out with a scathing diss of a recent ex, rather than finding a good man to begin with, and men are seen as strong for objectifying the women. Each gender wants to blame the other for most of the problems that exist, and everyone is so convinced of his side.
I don't pretend to know exactly why this situation exists, although I have a strong suspicion that it has to do with the nature of the family in black culture and the intervention of the state. Some people have speculated that the welfare state, which was originally created when the wealth gap between blacks and whites was narrowing, is what drove such huge rift in black gender relations. It makes the man obsolete as the provider. Without a strong masculine figure around, there's nothing to reign in the obsessiveness over the infant that tends to occur naturally in women who merge and bond with their babies. There's nothing to balance out the matriarchal power, which may explain why so many black men perceive black women to be domineering, overbearing, and obsessively jealous. Maybe what we're actually seeing is the catastrophic effects that occur when a man is perceived to have no value to offer, and perceives himself to have no value to offer. All of the black men I've met who have spoken ill of black women have had horribly abusive histories at the hands of their mothers, who were abusive in childhood and increasingly neglectful as their sons grew. Something else I've generally noticed about black culture that I have absolutely no proof of is that the supposed "virtue" of the family, particularly around the mother, seems to be held more fervently than in white cultures. In school, if I ever said that I hated my mother to my white friends, they would tend to empathize and we would exchange stories. If I ever said that to my black friends, they would get wide-eyed and say, "But she's your mother! You should always love your mother." It always seemed that they were under quite a bit more pressure than I was to uphold the mythology of the family despite the reality of the situation.
I also think that dating someone of a different skin color should have as much relevance as dating someone of a different hair color, but given these circumstances, I think people should make sure they're not dating interracially for the wrong reasons, such as a projection of one's familial experience onto an entire race. Although I have less experience talking to black women about this kind of thing, I would suppose that the negative perception of black men comes in large part from the way their father was devalued in the family. This is not to say that there are not patriarchal, abusive black fathers out there, because I know for a fact that there are, but the more common story I hear is about a father who was absent, either in person or in influence over the family unit. And I would guess that there's a lot of unexpressed, unconscious rage toward the father for not being there for protection and guidance.
I know it's probably a little offensive and annoying to have a white person try to explain everything about the black culture, but it's a subject I used to be very interested in for whatever reason, partly due to my former relationship. I found out the hard way that racism is still a really huge problem, even among educated people. There was a lot of racism in my extended family, and I had my suspicions that it was unconsious, unspoken of in my immediate family as well. They really did not want me dating a black person, but said it was because the world was so racist and they did not want me to experience the hardship that would come from that. I countered that I would not want to associate with people who were racist assholes anyway, and they said that I was too idealistic, shutting myself off from opportunities and the good parts of people. This absolutely baffled me at the time, but looking back, it's incredibly obvious as to why they would make these arguments. If you shouldn't associate or value people who were bigoted racists, then what business did they have associating with their own families?
Statelessness is next to godlessness.
The Blog!